My Response to the Extreme Uprisings in America
A White Paper on the Historical Weaponization of False Narratives Against Marginalized Communities
Abstract
Throughout history, disinformation has served as a powerful mechanism to maintain systems of oppression, creating hierarchies of belonging that privilege dominant groups while marginalizing those deemed “other.” This analysis examines how disinformation has been systematically deployed across centuries to justify discrimination against racial minorities, non-traditional families, women, and spiritual practitioners outside established religious institutions. Drawing from Harvard Law Review scholarship on the politics of belonging, historical analysis of eugenic pseudoscience, and contemporary examples of xenophobic rhetoric, this paper argues that disinformation functions as both a tool of social control and a form of spiritual violence that denies the sacred worth of all beings.
Introduction: The Architecture of Exclusion
The human tendency to create in-groups and out-groups becomes dangerous when coupled with the deliberate spread of false information designed to dehumanize those perceived as different. Racialized and xenophobic disinformation reinforces an anti-Black and anti-immigrant vision of America where powerful actors intentionally promulgate false information that becomes the norm defining who belongs in this country. This pattern extends beyond immigration and race to encompass attacks on women’s autonomy, non-traditional family structures, and spiritual practices that challenge dominant religious orthodoxy.
From a spiritual perspective that honors the interconnectedness of all life, disinformation represents a profound violation of sacred truth. It separates us from our essential unity and creates artificial barriers between human beings who share the same divine spark. As practitioners of earth-based spirituality understand, when we harm one part of the web of life, we damage the whole.
Chapter 1: The Historical Foundation of Exclusionary Disinformation
The Legal Codification of False Narratives
The Harvard Law Review analysis reveals how disinformation becomes embedded in legal structures, transforming lies into law. The law plays a powerful role in shaping society because the law reflects and reinforces the values, beliefs and power dynamics of the people who create and enforce the law. This process is particularly evident in the evolution of American citizenship laws, which have consistently privileged whiteness while excluding others based on fabricated claims about their fitness for belonging.
The 1790 Naturalization Act established the legal framework for this exclusion, limiting citizenship to “free white persons.” This seemingly neutral language masked a deeper system of racialized mythology that portrayed white Europeans as inherently superior and more deserving of full membership in American society. Chief Justice Taney relied upon the 1790 statute to provide the rationale for why Black people were not citizens. In the opinion, he employed racist rhetoric emphasizing that Black people were of “an inferior order, and altogether unfit to associate with the white race either in social or political relations” and “treated as an ordinary article of merchandise.”
The Persistence of Mythological Hierarchies
The court cases that followed, known as the “prerequisite cases,” reveal how judicial systems perpetuated disinformation by relying on popular prejudices rather than factual evidence. In deciding these naturalization cases, like the Court’s rationale in Dred Scott, the Court relied upon the opinion and common knowledge of the white ruling class in 1790. This “common knowledge” was nothing more than widely accepted falsehoods that served to maintain existing power structures.
The parallel to historical witch trials is striking. Both legal processes relied on popular prejudice and fabricated evidence to justify the persecution of those who threatened established order. Women healers, midwives, and wise women were branded as dangerous witches through disinformation campaigns that portrayed their knowledge as evil and their independence as threatening to patriarchal structures.
Chapter 2: The Pseudoscience of Superiority
Eugenics as Organized Disinformation
The eugenics movement of the late 19th and early 20th centuries represents perhaps the most systematic example of how disinformation can be dressed in scientific clothing to justify atrocities. Eugenics is an inaccurate theory linked to historical and present-day forms of discrimination, racism, ableism and colonialism. Despite lacking any legitimate scientific foundation, eugenic theories gained widespread acceptance because they provided an intellectually respectable veneer for existing prejudices.
Mainstream eugenics legitimised or (in the US and German cases in particular) actively promoted racism and provided it with a badge of scientific respectability and objectivity. This false scientific authority was used to justify forced sterilizations, immigration restrictions, and ultimately genocide, demonstrating how disinformation can escalate from social exclusion to mass violence.
The eugenic obsession with “racial purity” directly contradicted both scientific evidence and spiritual wisdom. We are 99.9% the same according to our DNA. Yet eugenic propaganda promoted the fiction that meaningful biological differences existed between racial groups, providing pseudo-scientific justification for systems of oppression.
Technology and the Amplification of Falsehoods
Modern technology has exponentially increased the power of disinformation to shape public opinion and policy. Social media platforms, sophisticated propaganda techniques, and data manipulation allow false narratives to spread with unprecedented speed and reach. The same tools that could be used to promote understanding and connection are instead weaponized to divide communities and spread fear.
The digital age has also seen the rise of sophisticated disinformation campaigns targeting women’s reproductive rights, LGBTQ+ individuals, and religious minorities. These campaigns often employ traditional stereotypes and fears, but distribute them through new channels that make them appear more credible and widespread than they actually are.
Chapter 3: The Targeting of Women and Non-Traditional Families
The Patriarchal Construction of “Natural” Order
Throughout history, disinformation has been used to maintain patriarchal control by promoting false narratives about women’s nature, capabilities, and proper roles in society. These campaigns have consistently portrayed women’s independence, sexuality, and spiritual power as dangerous to social order.
The witch trials of the 15th-17th centuries exemplify this pattern. Women who possessed knowledge of herbal medicine, practiced midwifery, or showed signs of economic independence were systematically targeted through disinformation campaigns that portrayed them as evil, sexually deviant, and in league with dark forces. The Malleus Maleficarum, a 15th-century treatise on witchcraft, codified many of these false beliefs into what appeared to be authoritative doctrine.
Similarly, contemporary attacks on reproductive rights rely on medically inaccurate information about pregnancy, contraception, and abortion. These campaigns deliberately spread false claims about fetal development, the safety of medical procedures, and the motivations of women seeking reproductive healthcare, all designed to justify legal restrictions on women’s autonomy.
The Demonization of Non-Traditional Families
Disinformation campaigns have consistently targeted family structures that deviate from patriarchal norms. Single mothers, same-sex couples, polyamorous families, and other non-traditional arrangements are subjected to false narratives that portray them as harmful to children and society.
These campaigns ignore extensive research demonstrating that family structure is less important than the presence of love, stability, and support in determining children’s wellbeing. Instead, they promote idealized myths about nuclear families that never reflected the reality of human family diversity throughout history.
The spiritual dimension of these attacks is particularly significant. Many earth-based and indigenous spiritual traditions recognize diverse family structures as natural and beneficial, understanding that children thrive when surrounded by extended networks of caring adults. The insistence on rigid family structures reflects not divine will but human attempts to control and limit the expression of love and kinship.
Chapter 4: Religious Extremism and Spiritual Oppression
The Weaponization of Sacred Texts
Religious extremism often relies on the deliberate misinterpretation of sacred texts to justify oppression and violence. This represents a profound form of spiritual disinformation, where the genuine wisdom of religious traditions is distorted to serve political and social agendas that contradict the fundamental teachings of compassion and love.
Christian extremism, in particular, has frequently employed selective biblical interpretation to justify slavery, segregation, the oppression of women, and the persecution of religious minorities. These interpretations ignore the broader biblical themes of justice, mercy, and universal human dignity in favor of isolated passages taken out of context and stripped of their historical meaning.
This selective interpretation represents a fundamental betrayal of authentic Christian teaching, which emphasizes love for all humanity and care for the marginalized. The same pattern appears in extremist interpretations of other religious traditions, where the universal messages of compassion are subordinated to narrow political objectives.
The Suppression of Indigenous and Alternative Spiritualities
The history of European colonization includes systematic campaigns to destroy indigenous spiritual traditions through disinformation that portrayed them as primitive, evil, or backwards. These campaigns justified the forced conversion of indigenous peoples and the destruction of their sacred sites, artifacts, and ceremonies.
The characterization of indigenous practices as “paganism” or “witchcraft” served to dehumanize entire populations and justify their conquest and exploitation. This spiritual colonization accompanied and enabled physical colonization, as the destruction of indigenous spiritual traditions weakened community bonds and cultural resistance.
Contemporary attacks on earth-based spiritualities, including Wicca, paganism, and other nature-centered traditions, continue this pattern. These practices are often mischaracterized as “Satanic” or dangerous, despite their emphasis on harmony with nature, personal responsibility, and ethical living. Such disinformation serves to marginalize practitioners and maintain the dominance of mainstream religious institutions.
Chapter 5: Contemporary Manifestations and Persistent Patterns
The Continuity of Exclusionary Rhetoric
Present day disinformation rhetoric is strikingly similar to that of the 1880s against Chinese immigrants, demonstrating the persistent nature of exclusionary narratives. The Harvard Law Review analysis documents how contemporary anti-immigrant rhetoric echoes historical patterns, using dehumanizing language and fabricated claims to justify discrimination and violence.
The targeting of Haitian immigrants in Springfield, Ohio, provides a recent example of how these patterns continue. Present day disinformation about Haitian migrants in Springfield, Ohio resulted in 30 bomb threats against municipal buildings, elementary schools and hospitals. The false claims about immigrants eating pets directly parallel historical accusations made against Chinese immigrants in the 1880s, revealing the recycled nature of xenophobic disinformation.
The Intersection of Multiple Oppressions
Modern disinformation campaigns often target individuals and communities that embody multiple marginalized identities. Women of color, LGBTQ+ individuals from religious minority backgrounds, and immigrants who practice non-Christian faiths face particularly intense and multifaceted attacks.
“Ethnic wedge issues are rhetorical tools intended to splinter the support of a key opponent by employing narratives of ethnically motivated discrimination, victimization, or exclusion, and promising remedial action.” These tactics deliberately attempt to divide potential allies and weaken coalitions fighting for justice and equality.
The spiritual violence of these intersectional attacks is profound, as they deny not only the political and social rights of targeted individuals but also their fundamental sacred worth as expressions of divine creativity. From a perspective that honors the interconnectedness of all life, such attacks wound the entire web of existence.
Chapter 6: The Spiritual Dimension of Truth and Healing
Sacred Truth as Resistance
From the perspective of earth-based spirituality, truth is not merely factual accuracy but a sacred principle that connects us to the divine source of all existence. Disinformation represents a fundamental violation of this sacred truth, creating separation where unity exists and promoting fear where love should flourish.
The role of spiritual practitioners, particularly those in leadership positions like High Priestesses, includes serving as guardians of sacred truth. This responsibility extends beyond ritual and ceremony to include speaking truth in the face of lies that harm vulnerable communities. The ancient role of the wise woman or medicine person included not only healing physical ailments but also addressing the spiritual diseases of hatred, fear, and separation.
The Healing Power of Authentic Narrative
Healing from the trauma of disinformation requires the restoration of authentic narratives that honor the full humanity and sacred worth of all people. This process involves not only correcting false information but also addressing the spiritual wounds created by systematic dehumanization.
Indigenous traditions often speak of the importance of story in healing both individuals and communities. When dominant narratives consistently portray certain groups as less than human, the process of healing requires the creation and amplification of counter-narratives that restore dignity and sacred worth.
The practice of bearing witness, common to many spiritual traditions, becomes particularly important in this context. By honestly acknowledging the harm caused by disinformation while also holding space for healing and transformation, spiritual practitioners can contribute to the restoration of truth and justice.
Practices for Discernment and Protection
Spiritual traditions offer numerous practices for developing discernment and protecting oneself from the harmful effects of disinformation. These include:
Meditation and Contemplation: Regular spiritual practice helps develop the inner clarity necessary to distinguish truth from falsehood and recognize the underlying motivations behind different narratives.
Community Discernment: Gathering with others who share a commitment to truth and justice provides collective wisdom that can identify and counter disinformation more effectively than individual efforts.
Ancestral Wisdom: Drawing on the teachings of those who have successfully resisted oppression in the past provides guidance for contemporary challenges.
Ritual Cleansing: Ceremonies that clear negative energy and restore spiritual balance can help heal from the trauma of exposure to dehumanizing narratives.
Sacred Activism: Engaging in social justice work as a form of spiritual practice, understanding that working to dismantle systems of oppression is itself a form of devotion to the divine.
Chapter 7: Pathways to Transformation
Legal and Political Reform
Addressing the systemic nature of disinformation requires comprehensive legal and political reform. This includes:
Media Literacy Education: Teaching critical thinking skills that enable people to identify and resist disinformation campaigns.
Platform Accountability: Holding social media companies and other information distributors accountable for the content they amplify and the algorithms they use.
Legal Remedies: Developing legal frameworks that address the harm caused by disinformation while protecting legitimate free speech rights.
Electoral Reform: Addressing the ways in which disinformation corrupts democratic processes and undermines fair elections.
Cultural and Social Change
Beyond legal reform, transformation requires broader cultural shifts that:
Center Marginalized Voices: Amplifying the stories and perspectives of those who have been targeted by disinformation campaigns.
Promote Inclusive Education: Teaching accurate history that acknowledges both the harm caused by oppression and the resilience of targeted communities.
Build Coalition: Creating alliances across different marginalized communities to resist divide-and-conquer tactics.
Support Alternative Media: Investing in media sources that prioritize accuracy and serve marginalized communities.
Spiritual Renewal
The deepest level of transformation requires spiritual renewal that:
Recognizes Universal Sacred Worth: Affirming that all beings are expressions of divine creativity deserving of respect and dignity.
Heals Historical Trauma: Addressing the spiritual wounds caused by generations of oppression and dehumanization.
Cultivates Compassion: Developing the capacity to see the humanity in those who have been misled by disinformation while maintaining firm boundaries against harmful behavior.
Restores Right Relationship: Rebuilding connections between people and between humans and the natural world that have been damaged by systems of oppression.
Conclusion: The Call to Sacred Resistance
The analysis presented in this paper reveals disinformation not merely as a political tactic but as a profound spiritual violence that wounds both individuals and communities. The intersection of race, immigration, and disinformation reveals the deeply embedded ways in which American society constructs and maintains hierarchies of belonging. These hierarchies contradict both scientific evidence about human unity and spiritual wisdom about the interconnectedness of all life.
Addressing the enduring impact of disinformation on the racial stratification of American society requires us to continuously examine the information on which the narratives are produced, circulated, and adopted into law. This examination must include not only factual correction but also spiritual healing that addresses the deeper wounds created by systematic dehumanization.
The path forward requires what might be called “sacred resistance” – opposition to oppression that is grounded in spiritual principles of truth, love, and justice. This resistance recognizes that the fight against disinformation is ultimately a fight for the soul of humanity itself.
As practitioners of earth-based spirituality understand, healing occurs in relationship – between individuals, communities, and the living world of which we are all part. The work of countering disinformation and building more just societies is therefore inseparable from the work of spiritual healing and transformation.
The ancient wisdom that “as above, so below” “as within so without” reminds us that changes in consciousness create changes in the material world. By committing ourselves to truth, justice, and the recognition of universal sacred worth, we participate in the healing of our world and the creation of beloved community.
This is the ultimate calling of our time: to resist the forces of separation and fear while nurturing the seeds of love and unity that exist within every human heart. In doing so, we honor both the struggles of those who came before us and the possibilities of those who will come after.
The web of life is strong, but it requires our conscious participation to maintain its integrity. May we each find the courage to speak truth, defend the vulnerable, and work for a world where all beings can flourish in their full sacred dignity.
This analysis is offered in the spirit of service to truth and justice, recognizing that the path toward beloved community requires both rigorous intellectual work and deep spiritual commitment. May it contribute to the healing of our world and the restoration of right relationship among all beings.
References and Further Reading
- McKanders, Karla. “Politics of Belonging: Anti-Black Racism, Xenophobia, and Disinformation.” Harvard Law Review Blog, November 2024.
- National Human Genome Research Institute. “Eugenics and Scientific Racism.” Genome.gov.
- Multiple sources on the historical development of eugenics and scientific racism.
- Indigenous wisdom traditions and earth-based spiritual practices.
- Contemporary scholarship on disinformation, media literacy, and democratic resistance.
Note: This white paper represents an integration of legal scholarship, historical analysis, and spiritual wisdom in service of truth and justice. The author acknowledges the limitations of any single perspective and encourages readers to engage with multiple sources and viewpoints in their own journey toward understanding and action..
________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Love High Priestess of Agape Covens